Billmon’s op-ed on blogging in the LA Times has a lot of people navel gazing today. Given that I’ve been struggling with the question of my own relevance it seems timely.
Billmon takes issue with the fact that some of the top leftleaning bloggers (Kos and Atrios most notably) have achieved enough success to be self-sustaining financially and have arguably started to be taken seriously by the more mainstream press, as well as the political establishment.
In the process, a charmed circle of bloggers — those glib enough and ideologically safe enough to fit within the conventional media punditocracy — is gaining larger audiences and greater influence.
The fact that the New York Times would do a major Sunday story about left-leaning bloggers is a good sign – the mainstream media is starting to admit bloggers are something more than a bizarre new Internet fad. And I think that this is more a positive than a negative. I’ve always been more interested in results than in precess. Even if this blog is insignificant, people who more or less share my point of view are getting listened to, and that’s a good thing.
There are some bloggers who, I think, have let success go to their heads, but the number is small (the annoyingly smug Matt Yglesias being the most notable one). But overall, the successfull bloggers that I most liked do not seem to have been affected by success. Billmon is going through some sort of crisis of the soul, I suspect. What it is I don’t know and I am not going to speculate. I hope he’s OK, because his blog was consistently excellent and I’m sad he has decided to shutter the Whiskey Bar.
I’ll just add that the day Kevin Drum linked to a post here and I got 650 views in 18 hours was the day I realized exactly how big blogs really had gotten.
At any rate, blogging ablout blogging is somewhat of an exercise in navel gazing, something I’ve been doing too much of, so I won’t belabor the point.
Final side note – As it happens I have a Six Degrees connection in all of this – my husband was a co-worker of Kos’ before Kos went full-time with the blog. That does color my attitude a little.